Contract law · Other side's draft

Review the other side's NDA before the client signs

A non-disclosure agreement usually arrives shortly before a meeting and is meant to be signed quickly. The agent team rates every clause with a traffic light, depending on whether the client discloses or receives information, and drafts the reply to the other side with concrete wording. The draft only goes out after your approval.

  • BRAO compliant
  • Data stored in Germany
  • Nothing goes out without your approval

What has little to do with confidentiality often hides in the small print

A non-solicitation clause, a contractual penalty without fault, rights to the client's own results: such clauses turn up precisely in the drafts meant to be signed quickly. Whether a clause is too strict depends on whether the client discloses or receives information. And after the first reply, a counter-draft often follows that has to be compared clause by clause again.

How an NDA file runs in rightflow

  1. 01

    The NDA is read: parties, purpose, direction, term, governing law and jurisdiction. If it is unclear whether the client discloses, receives or both, the team asks that first. A date given for reply or signature is entered as a deadline.

    Today
    Read the contract from start to finish
    Result
    Role, purpose and deadline in the file
  2. 02

    Every clause is rated with a traffic light and a reason, the green ones included. A clause that should be there but is missing is listed as its own point.

    Today
    Annotate clauses one by one
    Result
    Traffic-light list of all clauses
  3. 03

    The reply letter is drafted with proposed wording for every red and amber clause, except changes the client has waived.

    Today
    Phrase requested changes from scratch
    Result
    Reply letter drafted
  4. 04

    A second agent checks the draft against the file before it is put to you for approval.

    Today
    Proofread when someone has time
    Result
    Second check before approval
  5. 05

    Only after your approval does a short email with the letter attached go to the other side; the client receives a copy.

    Today
    Send the letter by hand
    Result
    Email to the other side drafted
  6. 06

    When a counter-draft arrives, every clause is rated again: which demands were accepted, which rejected, which clauses are new. Once all must-have changes are in, the client is told they can sign.

    Today
    Lay versions side by side
    Result
    Record of every negotiation round

What you have in the file

The traffic-light list

All clauses with rating and reason, missing clauses included.

The reply letter

With proposed wording for every red and amber clause, in the language of the NDA.

The deadline

A date given for reply or signature, as a deadline in the file.

The negotiation rounds

Every version from the other side and every reply, with date and result.

For firms with business clients

  • Firms advising businesses on contracts on an ongoing basis and reviewing the other side's NDAs at short notice.
  • Firms whose clients regularly receive non-disclosure agreements ahead of cooperations, pilot projects or supply relationships.

What the agent team takes on for NDA review

Coordinating agent
  1. 01
    Clarifying the role

    Whether the client discloses, receives or both, because the rating depends on it.

  2. 02
    Rating clauses

    Purpose, exceptions, onward disclosure, term, penalty, unrelated clauses, whistleblowers, governing law and jurisdiction.

  3. 03
    Drafting the reply

    Short proposed wording for every red and amber clause.

  4. 04
    Securing the deadline

    A date given for reply or signature, as a deadline in the file.

  5. 05
    Comparing counter-drafts

    Accepted, rejected and new clauses, round by round.

  6. 06
    Informing the client

    If they want to sign quickly themselves, a short assessment; once everything needed is in, the message that they can sign.

What the team knows

  • Trade secrets and permitted disclosure under the German Trade Secrets Act (§§ 2, 5 GeschGehG).

  • Contractual penalties and their reduction (§§ 340, 343 BGB), the exception for merchants (§ 348 HGB).

  • Review of standard terms (§§ 305, 307 BGB) and non-solicitation clauses (§ 75f HGB).

  • Reports under the German Whistleblower Protection Act (§ 39 HinSchG) and competition law limits (§ 1 GWB).

  • Your house rules: letterhead, salutation and standard wording, set once.

When the file is not clear-cut

  • The situation

    It is unclear whether the client discloses or receives information

    What the team does

    The team asks that first, because the rating depends on it.

  • The situation

    The client both discloses and receives

    What the team does

    The team puts the clauses where the two views conflict to you for a decision before the reply.

  • The situation

    Whether a non-compete between competitors is open to challenge under competition law is unclear

    What the team does

    The team puts the question to you with the possible routes and follows your decision.

What the team does not take on yet

This is where the team's work ends. Anything beyond it stays with you and your firm.

  • No marked-up draft with tracked changes; the proposed wording is in the reply letter.
  • Foreign law is only flagged as a risk, not reviewed.
  • For an NDA on a company acquisition or between competitors who are to exchange prices, customers or offers, no reply is drafted; the clauses are put to you with a note that they need separate review.
  • Competition law questions are decided by the firm.
  • The team only states the cost of the matter as you have set up your billing.

Other case types

See an NDA file in rightflow.

In 30 minutes we show you, using a real NDA, how the team rates every clause and prepares the reply.