Tax law · Owner side

Challenge the error in the right property tax assessment before the deadline runs out

Under German law, an error can only be challenged in the assessment where it arises. The agent team sorts the assessments, recalculates them line by line and drafts the objection or application for amendment to the tax office or the municipality. The draft only goes out after your approval.

  • BRAO compliant
  • Data stored in Germany
  • Nothing goes out without your approval

Three assessments, two authorities, one error in exactly one place

Since 2025, German property tax (Grundsteuer) has been levied on new values, and the assessments often contain errors: a wrong living area, a wrong year of construction, a wrong co-ownership share or a base amount carried incorrectly into the tax assessment. Property tax value, base amount and tax are set by the tax office and the municipality in separate assessments, each with its own deadline. Challenging the wrong assessment means losing.

How a property tax file runs in rightflow

  1. 01

    Every assessment is recorded on its own, even when one letter contains several: type, authority, legal remedy and reference date, together with the property data as the assessment states them.

    Today
    Sort the assessments apart
    Result
    Every assessment on its own in the file
  2. 02

    Every objection deadline is calculated under § 122 of the German Fiscal Code (AO) and entered, with a follow-up one week before it ends.

    Today
    Calculate each deadline by hand
    Result
    Every deadline with follow-up
  3. 03

    The team compares the data in the assessments with the evidence and recalculates value, base amount and tax. It shows the assessed value, the calculated value and the first stage that deviates.

    Today
    Recalculate the income value by hand
    Result
    Recalculation line by line
  4. 04

    The draft is made against the assessment that carries the error: objection or, once final, an application for amendment or correction, with a specific application and evidence. If the review is not finished by the advance reminder, it is first filed to save the deadline.

    Today
    Letter to the wrong authority
    Result
    Letter to the right authority drafted
  5. 05

    A second agent checks the draft against the file before it is put to you for approval: every figure as in the recalculation, every error with evidence.

    Today
    Proofread when someone has time
    Result
    Second check before approval
  6. 06

    When an amended assessment arrives, the team checks whether the change reaches the assessments that follow from it. On a reminder or announced enforcement, it drafts the application for suspension of enforcement.

    Today
    Follow-on assessments go unchecked
    Result
    Change followed through to the tax

What you have in the file

Every deadline

For each assessment, calculated under § 122 AO, with the public holidays where the authority sits and a follow-up one week before.

The recalculation

Assessed and calculated value line by line, with the first stage that deviates.

The letter

Objection or application for amendment or correction, with a specific application and evidence.

Message to the client

The assessments in plain words, the deadlines, the missing documents and the fact that the property tax must still be paid.

For firms with tax and real estate matters

  • Firms representing owners of residential property under the new German property tax.
  • Firms reviewing many similar assessments for homeowners' associations or property managers.

What the agent team takes on for property tax objections

Coordinating agent
  1. 01
    Sorting the assessments

    Property tax value, base amount and tax assessment recorded separately, with authority and legal remedy.

  2. 02
    Securing the deadlines

    Every deadline calculated from notification and entered, with a follow-up one week before it ends.

  3. 03
    Comparing the data

    Living area, year of construction, plot area and co-ownership share against the tax return, land register, declaration of division and building documents.

  4. 04
    Recalculating

    Property tax value, equivalence amounts, base amount and tax, and whether the tax assessment matches the base amount.

  5. 05
    Drafting the letter

    Objection or application for amendment or correction to the authority whose assessment carries the error.

  6. 06
    Clarifying payment

    Notice that payment continues; on a reminder or enforcement, the application for suspension of enforcement.

What the team knows

  • Notification and deadlines under § 122 AO, with four days from 2025.

  • The income value method of the federal model under §§ 252 to 257 of the German Valuation Act (BewG) and proof of a lower value under § 220(2) BewG.

  • The state laws of Lower Saxony and Bavaria (NGrStG, BayGrStG).

  • Correction, amendment and error-correcting update of final assessments (§§ 129, 173, 173a AO, § 222 BewG).

  • Your house rules: letterhead, salutation and standard wording, set once.

When the file is not clear-cut

  • The situation

    The assessment's calculation is correct

    What the team does

    Any error then lies in the data, and the team checks it against the evidence.

  • The situation

    The client thinks the market value is lower, but there is no expert report

    What the team does

    The team asks you whether one should be commissioned.

  • The situation

    The client says the assessment arrived later

    What the team does

    The team still calculates the deadline from statutory notification and records the statement in the file.

What the team does not take on yet

This is where the team's work ends. Anything beyond it stays with you and your firm.

  • The team does not draft court actions or urgent court applications. It secures the deadline and puts the decision to you.
  • The asset value method for commercial and mixed-use property and the state models of Baden-Württemberg, Hamburg and Hesse are not recalculated. There the team checks the data in the assessments against the evidence.
  • The team checks the base rate only in Bavaria, Lower Saxony and Saxony. In the other states it takes it from the assessment and marks it as unchecked.
  • No expert report is commissioned, and the team does not advise stopping payment.
  • The standard land value and the municipal multiplier come from the assessment or as a document in the file, not from the internet.

Other case types

See a property tax file in rightflow.

In 30 minutes we show you, using real assessments, how the team sorts and recalculates them and prepares the objection to the right authority.